From Manasquan, New Jersey, Cluley posted an illustrious three-year track record at William & Mary. As a three-year starter, Cluley ranks in the top-10 in school history in seven categories – sixth in passing yards (6,864), sixth in total offense (7,128), fourth in passing attempts (959), third in passing completions (577), tied for fifth in completion percentage (60.2), eighth in passing touchdowns (39) and seventh in 200-yard passing performances (16).
Cluley impressed scouts with his size, accuracy, and ability to protect the football. In addition to earning All-Colonial Athletic Association honors, he received an invitation by the New York Giants to attend mini-camp. In 2019, at age 25, Cluley will take his talents to Austin to suit up in front of scouts at The Spring League.